Why Gen Z's Love for Haul Culture Is Driving Record-High Return Rates

Haul Culture and Its Impact: Why Gen Z's Shopping Habits Are Leading to Increased Returns

Haul culture has taken over, and shopping has never looked so aesthetic. Scroll through TikTok, and you’ll see countless videos of people unboxing mountains of clothes, shoes, and accessories—each haul bigger than the last. It’s more than a trend; it’s a lifestyle. But behind the perfectly folded piles of clothes and the "haul flex" hashtags, there’s a hidden ripple effect: skyrocketing return rates.

Gen Z is shopping online more than any other generation, and let’s just say, the “buy now, decide later” approach is thriving. Ordering five sizes of the same top to “find the right fit”? Standard practice. Buying a dress purely for the haul video? Been there. But here’s the catch: what doesn’t work gets returned, creating logistical chaos for brands and a mounting environmental cost.

As retailers scramble to handle the flood of returns, they’re rethinking how to cater to haul culture while encouraging smarter shopping. And for us? It’s time to ask: is this vibe sustainable—or are we just maxing out our carts and patience at the same time?

What Is Haul Culture?

Haul culture is all about showcasing massive shopping sprees, often through social media platforms like TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube. It’s not just about buying things—it’s about the flex. Think unboxing videos where influencers or everyday shoppers reveal dozens of items they’ve snagged in one go, from trendy clothes to home decor or beauty products.

The appeal? It’s equal parts entertainment, inspiration, and a little bit of envy. Watching someone pull item after item out of their shopping bags is oddly satisfying, and for many, it sparks the urge to replicate the experience.

But haul culture isn’t just fun and games. Beneath the glossy aesthetics lies a deeper story about overconsumption, impulsive buying, and the ripple effects of returning items that didn’t make the cut. Haul culture is more than just a trend—it’s a snapshot of how Gen Z interacts with shopping today.

Why Are We Returning So Much?

The short answer? We’re over-ordering like pros. Think about it: when was the last time you ordered just one item online? For many of us, shopping digitally means tossing five sizes of the same dress into our cart “just to see which fits best” or buying items we know we’ll probably return, purely for the content. It’s all part of the game—find the best, return the rest.

For Gen Z, online shopping is basically second nature. We’re digital natives, raised in a world where e-commerce is king. Shopping apps are our playgrounds, and free shipping makes clicking “add to cart” way too easy. But unlike walking into a physical store where you can see, touch, and try on clothes, online shopping comes with a lot of guesswork. Sizing is inconsistent across brands, colors look different on-screen, and quality doesn’t always match those polished product photos. The result? More often than not, we’re left with a pile of items that just don’t work.

"I ordered like 15 things for a wedding and ended up keeping one," says Kelsey, 22, Portland, OR. "Returns are just part of the process now. It’s not like in-store shopping where you know what you’re getting."

And let’s not ignore the role of haul culture. Influencers flood our feeds with unboxings, showing off dozens of trendy pieces bought in bulk. It creates this FOMO-fueled pressure to consume, even if we don’t need—or even really want—half the stuff we’re buying. Sure, it’s fun to watch, but for many of us, it sets off a chain reaction: we mimic the behavior, over-order, and then deal with the hassle of returning items that looked better on TikTok than in real life.

The numbers back it up: according to recent reports, return rates for online shopping have surged to an average of 30%–40%, with fashion being the biggest offender. For comparison, in-store return rates hover around 8–10%. Clearly, our cart-happy habits are reshaping retail.

How Brands Are Handling It

Returns might be second nature for us, but for companies? They’re a logistical and financial nightmare. Every time we send something back, brands have to deal with restocking, repackaging, inspecting, and often, eating the shipping costs. Studies show that processing returns can cost retailers 15%–30% of the item’s original price. Multiply that by millions of returns, and you’ve got a major headache.

In response, some companies are introducing policies to make us think twice. Charging for returns, like Zara’s $1.95 fee, is becoming more common. Others are scaling back on free shipping perks, especially for small or frequent orders. These changes aren’t always popular, but they reflect the growing cost of catering to over-ordering habits.

At the same time, brands are getting tech-savvy. Platforms like ASOS and Zara now offer virtual try-on features, allowing shoppers to visualize how items will fit before buying. Amazon is leveraging AI to recommend sizes based on purchase history and returns, making it easier to guess correctly the first time. Even companies like Warby Parker are offering home try-on programs for select items, minimizing unnecessary shipments.

Sustainability-focused brands are going one step further. They’re using haul culture as a talking point, encouraging shoppers to buy intentionally instead of impulsively. Take Patagonia, for example, which promotes its “Buy Less, Buy Better” ethos. It’s a bold move in a world obsessed with overconsumption, but it’s one that’s gaining traction with eco-conscious consumers.

Ultimately, it’s a balancing act. Hauls are fun, and brands know we’re not giving them up anytime soon. But by combining tech innovations with mindful messaging, retailers are finding ways to cater to our shopping habits while reducing the chaos of endless returns. It’s a win-win for everyone—if we’re willing to play along.

"I love doing hauls, but lately I’ve started shopping smarter," says Jordan, 24, Austin, TX. "I still buy what I need, but I try to think twice before grabbing a ton of stuff I’ll probably send back."

The Environmental Cost of Returns

Returns don’t just dent brands’ wallets—they take a massive toll on the environment too. Every item shipped back racks up carbon emissions, whether it’s from trucks, planes, or ships. Then there’s the packaging: returned goods often require new boxes, tags, or plastic wrapping to be resold, generating even more waste. But the most shocking part? A huge chunk of returns never even makes it back to shelves.

Studies show that 25%–50% of returned products, especially in fast fashion, are discarded rather than resold. Why? It’s often cheaper and faster for companies to toss items into landfills or send them to incinerators than to process and restock them. This waste contributes to overflowing landfills and unnecessary greenhouse gas emissions—hardly the vibe for a generation that claims to love the planet.

For Gen Z, who often pride ourselves on eco-conscious choices, haul culture presents a tough contradiction. It’s fun to snag a deal or showcase a big shopping spree, but the environmental cost of over-ordering and returns can’t be ignored. Small changes—like buying thoughtfully, avoiding impulse hauls, and supporting sustainable brands—can help reduce our impact. If we want to make real progress, it’s time to put our values into action.

How Haul Culture Impacts Smaller Businesses

While major retailers like Amazon and Zara can absorb the financial blow of constant returns, smaller businesses aren’t as lucky. Independent shops and e-commerce startups often operate with limited inventory and slim profit margins, meaning every return hits much harder. Unlike larger companies, they can’t easily afford restocking fees, extra packaging, or the labor costs that come with processing a return.

The ripple effect is real. Frequent returns can disrupt stock levels, leaving small businesses scrambling to replace items or hold excess inventory they can’t sell. This delay can stall operations, hurt cash flow, and even push prices higher for other customers as a way to cover costs. For brands that rely on loyal customers to survive, it’s a tough position to be in.

For Gen Z shoppers, who love supporting indie brands and “shopping small,” haul culture creates an unintentional problem. While it’s tempting to order items in bulk “just to try,” this practice can lead to financial strain for the very businesses we claim to love. Being mindful—double-checking sizes, reading reviews, or asking questions before buying—can make all the difference. Supporting small brands is about more than buying; it’s about respecting their hard work and resources, too.

The Psychology Behind Haul Culture

Why are we so hooked on hauls? It’s not just about owning new clothes or accessories—it’s about the rush. Every time we click “checkout,” we get a hit of dopamine, the brain’s feel-good chemical that rewards us for indulging in instant gratification. The thrill doesn’t stop there. The moment that package arrives, there’s the unboxing high, a ritual that’s as much about the experience as the items inside. It’s why haul videos on TikTok and Instagram feel so satisfying—they tap into that shared excitement, turning shopping into entertainment and hauls into a badge of honor.

But here’s where it gets complicated. The same brain chemistry that fuels the high of buying can make the return process feel like a chore. Returns are tedious, time-consuming, and let’s be honest, they kill the vibe. That’s why so many of us procrastinate or avoid returning items altogether, even if they’re just collecting dust in the corner of our rooms.

Breaking the haul culture cycle starts with understanding it. Shopping mindfully—asking ourselves if we really need an item or if it’s just about the dopamine hit—can help. Hauls can still be fun, but they don’t have to come at the cost of endless returns or unnecessary waste.

Is Haul Culture Here to Stay?

Haul culture isn’t going anywhere anytime soon. It’s fun, satisfying, and let’s admit it—a little addictive. But as much as we love unboxing new finds, the reality of endless returns is starting to sink in. Between the environmental impact, wasted resources, and brands tightening their return policies, it’s clear that change is on the horizon.

The good news? Gen Z is all about self-awareness. While we’ve embraced haul culture, many of us are starting to shop more intentionally—whether that’s thinking twice before ordering or supporting sustainable brands. The excitement of a haul doesn’t have to mean overconsumption; it’s about finding that balance between loving fashion and respecting its footprint.

Retailers, too, are stepping up with solutions that make shopping smarter, from virtual try-ons to AI size recommendations. So, the next time you fill your cart, remember: a thoughtful haul hits just as hard as a massive one.

Keep exploring the trends shaping our generation right here at Woke Waves Magazine.

#HaulCulture #GenZShopping #ReturnsTrend #MindfulShopping #Sustainability